Why Public Speaking Makes You Nervous

At Mindful Presenter, we often hear from professionals about their struggles with public speaking anxiety, which is by far the most common issue they ask us to help with. Every week, we receive similar stories from individuals or HR directors sharing their concerns. Beneath these practical requests, there’s almost always a gentle admission: they feel something in them isn’t quite right, that everyone else seems to handle it easily, and that they wish nobody knew about their discomfort.

Neither is true, and the second isn’t even close.

You Are Not Nervous Because You Lack Confidence

An idea circulates widely in my industry, repeated by speakers and coaches who ought to know better: people who fear public speaking suffer from low self-esteem. For some, that may well be accurate, and I have met them. As a general explanation, it is lazy, and in fifteen years of standing in rooms with anxious, capable, accomplished professionals, I have found it to be true far less often than the people repeating it appear to believe.

The truth is simpler, and considerably kinder.

You Are Nervous Because You Care How You Come Across

That is the whole of it.

This need to look good in front of other people is among the most primitive things about us, and it has been with us for as long as we have lived in groups where reputation determined whether we ate. Psychologists give it a rather less flattering name, the fear of negative evaluation, and it sits at the centre of very nearly everything we understand about social anxiety.

You don’t need a formal diagnosis to understand what you’re feeling. Just recognising and accepting it can help, because it’s not going anywhere and was never meant to disappear. Some of us experience it more intensely than others, but remember, nobody is completely immune.

Three costumes for the same need

It rarely announces itself plainly. It arrives dressed as something else, and most of us feel all three versions of it somewhere on the walk to the front of the room.

– The need to know that we are going to be fine and that nothing bad is about to happen to us.

– The need to protect, and where possible improve, how people whose opinions we value think of us.

– The need to belong, which is the oldest of the three, and being heard is how we feel it.

These are not just three separate problems that need different solutions. Instead, they are three different sides of the same issue, and together, they are more than enough to overwhelm anyone. Let’s face them one step at a time.

We Are Hardwired To Care About Our Reputation

When you stand in front of a group of people you hope to influence, your reputation is genuinely at stake, and the part of you that has noticed this is not being irrational. It is being accurate.

People judge people. We all know this perfectly well, because we all do it, quickly and continuously and usually without ever admitting it to ourselves.

I have never once met a speaker who didn’t want to look good, or who honestly didn’t care how their presentation landed. It is very often the ones who care the most, who have prepared the most carefully and thought the hardest about the people in front of them, who are the most frightened. That is not a weakness. It is the clearest evidence available that the thing matters.

A Wedding, And A Groom Who Was Certain He Would Fail

I was at a friend’s wedding not long ago and spent part of the afternoon with the groom, a man I had not met before and liked immediately.

After the speeches, he confided that he had been excruciatingly nervous about his, had been rehearsing it for weeks, and had arrived genuinely convinced he would never get through it.

He gave one of the best, funniest, and most quietly moving wedding speeches I have had the pleasure of sitting through. The moment he finished, every guest in that room was on their feet.

Was he suffering from low self-esteem?

NO

Did he want to look good on his wedding day, in front of his wife and everybody he cares about?

OF COURSE

Was it reasonable for him to feel anxious?

YOU BET

Did he see a great deal at stake?

NATURALLY

He was not nervous because something was wrong with him. He was nervous because it was the most important room he had ever stood up in, because the people sitting in it were the people he loved most in the world, and because he knew exactly what it would cost him to get it wrong in front of them.

Where The Line Is

For most people, that is the entire story. Not a disorder, not damage, and not something that was done to them in a classroom when they were six years old. Simply the ordinary person wishing to be thought well of, turned up loud because on this particular occasion the stakes are visible and the audience is looking.

For a smaller number of people, it is more than that, and it matters that we say so plainly rather than sweep it in with everybody else. If the dread arrives days in advance and settles over the whole week, or if it has quietly begun to shape which roles you apply for and which meetings you find convincing reasons to miss, that deserves the attention of somebody properly qualified rather than a blog post. There is no shame in it, and it is a different conversation from this one.

Knowing which of the two you are looking at is the most useful thing you could do this week.

One Source That Almost Nobody Suspects

Another reason nerves arrive affects some of the most capable people I work with. Sometimes, you’re not anxious about speaking at all.

You are anxious because you do not believe what you have been asked to say, and some part of you already knows the room will not believe it either. Standing up to deliver something you privately consider thin is uncomfortable, and that discomfort is not stage fright. It is judgement, and it is usually correct.

When that is what is happening, the problem is in your content rather than in you, and it’s quicker to fix than you might think.

You Are Allowed To Find This Difficult

Life hands every one of us something, and the list is longer and a good deal stranger than anybody lets on.

Some of us:

– Are terrified of spiders.

– Will not get on a plane without a drink first.

– Are quietly certain that our suitcase will be the last one onto the carousel.

– Dread speaking in front of a group of people.

None of these makes you a lesser person, and you can work on each one.

The Good News

Just as you can learn to enjoy flying and to make a sort of peace with spiders, you can learn to turn the volume down on public speaking anxiety. Not to switch it off. Nobody switches it off, including me, and anybody who tells you they have either stopped caring or is not being straight with you, and I am not certain which of those is worse.

What changes is your relationship with it. The nerves stop deciding what you do, which opportunities you put yourself forward for, and whether you say the thing in the meeting that you walked in intending to say.

On the practical side, what to do with your breathing, your opening, your hands, and the night before, here are thirteen things that genuinely work, not one of which asks you to become somebody you are not.

Before any of them, though, this one matters. Stop treating your nerves as evidence against yourself. They are evidence that you care, and an audience will forgive almost anything in a speaker who cares and very little in one who does not.

If any of this was useful, please pass it on. There is somebody you work with who has been quietly carrying the belief that they are the only person in the building who feels like this, who has let the conference slot go to someone less able rather than stand up and take it, and who has never once been told that what they are feeling is not a flaw in them but the ordinary cost of caring how they come across. It will take you ten seconds, and they may read the one thing nobody has thought to say.

If you need help with public speaking anxiety:

– Book yourself onto a powerful public speaking course.

– Invest in some really good one to one public speaking coaching.

– Get yourself some excellent presentation skills training.

Image: Courtesy of: Canva.com