Authenticity in Public Speaking: Why “Just Be Yourself” Isn’t Enough

Authenticity is one of the most admired qualities in leadership and public speaking.

When someone speaks with honesty and presence, we feel it immediately. It’s refreshing, human and memorable, but authenticity isn’t as simple as “just be yourself.”

If only it were

Audiences today are highly discerning. They can sense insincerity instantly and disengage the moment something feels off, and the truth is, most of us don’t have just one self; we have many.

We Don’t Have One Self — We Have Several

Life shapes us into a whole collection of selves. These are just a few examples, as we all carry far more versions of ourselves than we often realise.

We have our:

– courageous self

– patient self

– persistent self

– compassionate self

And we also have our:

– frustrated self

– anxious self

– defensive self

– impatient self

So, when someone says, “be yourself,” the real question becomes:

Which self should take the stage?

Authenticity also isn’t a licence to turn up as the most unfiltered or under‑prepared version of ourselves.

I often hear speakers say, “I’m just being myself,” when what they really mean is, “I haven’t made the effort to bring my best self.” Nobody is born boring, but any of us can sound boring if we rely on habit rather than intention. Authenticity isn’t about settling for the easiest version of who we are; it’s about choosing the version that communicates with clarity, energy and purpose.

The Real Challenge: Choosing the Right Self for the Room

Authenticity in public speaking isn’t about expressing every emotion or impulse you have.

It’s about choosing the version of yourself that best serves your audience.

That means bringing forward your:

– mindful self

– respectful self

– focused self

– emotionally intelligent self

Authenticity is not a free‑for‑all; it’s a deliberate act of awareness, and it requires substance

Many speakers sound authentic because they speak with passion, energy or conviction. These qualities matter, but they’re not enough on their own.

Authenticity without substance becomes noise

True authenticity requires:

– clarity

– structure

– relevance

– value

It’s not just how you speak, it’s what you give your audience.

What Authentic Speakers Actually Do

Authentic speakers make intentional choices. They:

1. Make it about the audience

Authenticity is service, not self‑expression for its own sake.

2. Bring clarity, not chaos

Being “real” doesn’t mean rambling. It means coherence and flow.

3. Use emotion wisely

Emotion is powerful, but it must be grounded in awareness, not reactivity.

4. Focus on solutions

Anyone can point out problems. Authenticity offers direction.

5. Stay respectful

It doesn’t require belittling others or using sarcasm as a shield.

Authenticity Is a Choice

Authenticity, communication and leadership are complex. Our understanding of them is shaped by experience, belief and perception, but one thing is clear:

It is not an excuse for self‑indulgence; it’s a commitment to clarity, substance and service.

Authenticity fails when it:

– makes you look good by making others look bad

– encourages rambling instead of focus

– centres on bitterness rather than insight

– fixates on problems instead of solutions

Authenticity succeeds when it helps your audience think, feel and act differently, and that’s the version of “yourself” they deserve.

If you’d like to learn more about authenticity in public speaking:

– Book them onto a powerful public speaking course.

– Invest in some really good one to one public speaking coaching.

– Get your team some excellent presentation training

Image: Courtesy of Canva.com